Name: Indulge in This Irresistible Stuffed Cookie Pie Delight
Prep time: 20 min
Cook time: 30 min
Total time: 70 min
Ingredients: 1 cup Salted Butter (Can substitute with unsalted.); 1 cup Light Brown Sugar (Can replace with dark brown sugar.); 1 cup Granulated Sugar; 1 whole Egg; 1 whole Egg Yolk; 1 tablespoon Vanilla; 2.5 cups All-Purpose Flour (Can use gluten-free flour.); 1 teaspoon Cornstarch (Can be omitted.); 1 teaspoon Baking Soda (Do not substitute with baking powder.); 0.5 teaspoon Kosher Salt (Table salt can be used.); 1 cup Milk Chocolate Chips (Can substitute with dark chocolate chips.); 0.5 cup Creamy Peanut Butter (Almond butter can be used.); 1 cup Marshmallow Cream (Can substitute with vanilla frosting.); 0.5 cup Nutella (Can swap with any chocolate-hazelnut spread.); 0.5 cup White Chocolate Chips (Can omit or replace with milk chocolate chips.); 1 cup Mini Toblerone Candies (Can be replaced with similar nougat candies.); 1 cup Mini Reese's Peanut Butter Cups (Can substitute with chocolate truffles.); 0.5 cup Dark Chocolate Chips (Optional for drizzle.); 1 cup Butterfinger Pieces (Can substitute with crushed graham crackers.)

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

The aroma of freshly baked cookies wafted through the kitchen, wrapping me in a warm, comforting embrace. It’s incredible how the simple act of baking can transform an ordinary day into a celebration—especially when you’re whipping up this Decadent Chocolate Peanut Butter Stuffed Cookie Pie. Bursting with a chewy cookie crust cradling a luscious filling of creamy peanut butter, divine Nutella, and dreamy marshmallow cream, this dessert is a true crowd-pleaser. Not only is it perfect for gatherings, but you’ll also love how easily it can be prepped ahead of time and served at room temperature, making it an ideal choice for those busy days when you’re craving something extraordinary. Are you ready to elevate your dessert game with this indulgent treat? Let’s dive in!

Why is Stuffed Cookie Pie So Irresistible?

Indulgence Awaits: This stuffed cookie pie is not just a dessert; it’s a celebration of flavors that will wow your taste buds.
Easy Prep: With straightforward steps, even novice bakers can master this recipe, making it a foolproof addition to your dessert repertoire.
Crowd Favorite: The combination of creamy peanut butter and Nutella creates a filling that will have everyone coming back for seconds—perfect for parties!
Versatile Variations: Want to switch things up? Try mixing in different candies or swapping peanut butter for almond butter for a nutty twist.
Perfect Pairing: Serve it warm with a dollop of vanilla ice cream or drizzle with chocolate for an extra touch of decadence.
Let your kitchen be the place where comfort and joy meet, just like the delightful layers of this pie!

Stuffed Cookie Pie Ingredients

For the Cookie Crust
• Salted Butter – Adds richness and moisture; substitute unsalted for a less salty taste.
• Light Brown Sugar – Provides sweetness and a chewy texture; can replace with dark brown sugar for a deeper flavor.
• Granulated Sugar – Sweetens the dough; maintain sugar balance for texture.
• Egg + Egg Yolk – Enhances richness and structure; use a flax egg for a vegan option.
• Vanilla – Adds flavor depth; no substitutions needed for best results.
• All-Purpose Flour – Forms the cookie crust; use gluten-free flour for a gluten-free option.
• Cornstarch – Improves texture and softness; can be omitted, but may alter texture slightly.
• Baking Soda – Leavening agent for a chewy cookie; do not substitute with baking powder without adjusting quantities.
• Kosher Salt – Balances sweetness; table salt can be used but reduce quantity.
• Milk Chocolate Chips – Adds sweetness and meltiness; substitute with dark chocolate chips for a less sweet profile.

For the Filling
• Creamy Peanut Butter – The primary filling ingredient; almond butter can be used as a substitute.
• Marshmallow Cream – Adds a fluffy texture; substitute with vanilla frosting if necessary.
• Nutella – Contributes chocolate flavor and creaminess; can be swapped with any chocolate-hazelnut spread.
• White Chocolate Chips – Enhances sweetness; can omit or replace with milk chocolate chips.
• Mini Toblerone Candies – Adds texture and a unique twist; can be replaced with similar nougat candies.
• Mini Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups – Stuffed within the pie for texture; can substitute with chocolate truffles or omit.

For the Topping
• Dark Chocolate Chips (for drizzle) – Adds a finishing touch; optional but recommended for a flavor contrast.
• Butterfinger Pieces (to sprinkle) – Adds crunch and extra sweetness; can substitute with crushed graham crackers.

Get ready to indulge in a delightful journey with each bite of your homemade Stuffed Cookie Pie!

Step‑by‑Step Instructions for Stuffed Cookie Pie

Step 1: Prep Dough
In a large mixing bowl, beat together 1 cup of salted butter and both sugars until the mixture is creamy and well combined—about 2 minutes. Add in one egg, one egg yolk, and 1 tablespoon of vanilla, mixing until smooth. The dough should have a rich, buttery flavor, setting the foundation for your Stuffed Cookie Pie.

Step 2: Mix Dry Ingredients
Gradually sift in 2½ cups of all-purpose flour along with 1 teaspoon of cornstarch, 1 teaspoon of baking soda, and ½ teaspoon of kosher salt. Mix until just combined; be careful not to overwork the dough. Finally, fold in 1 cup of milk chocolate chips for a delightful sweetness that will balance the decadent filling.

Step 3: Layer Dough in Pan
Divide the dough into three equal parts—this will help create the irresistible layers. Use two-thirds of the dough to press into the bottom and sides of an 8-inch springform pan, ensuring it’s even and thick enough to hold the fillings inside. Leave one-third of the dough aside for topping, which will complete your Stuffed Cookie Pie.

Step 4: Add Fillings
Melt ½ cup of creamy peanut butter in the microwave for about 30 seconds until soft, then pour it evenly into the cookie crust. Layer mini Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups followed by ½ cup of Nutella, ½ cup of white chocolate chips, 1 cup of marshmallow cream, and a sprinkle of mini Toblerone candies on top. Each layer will add a luscious texture to your pie.

Step 5: Finish with Dough
Carefully spread the reserved dough over the filling, sealing the edges to lock everything in. Make sure it covers the filling entirely, leaving no gaps. Place the pie in the freezer for about 1 hour, allowing it to firm up and hold its shape during baking.

Step 6: Bake
Preheat your oven to 350°F (175°C) with convection settings. Bake your Stuffed Cookie Pie for approximately 30 minutes, or until the top is lightly golden and the edges are set. The aroma will fill your kitchen, signaling that your delicious dessert is nearly ready.

Step 7: Cool
Remove the pie from the oven and let it cool at room temperature for about 20 minutes. For the best flavors to meld, cover and refrigerate the pie overnight. This ensures that each slice maintains its perfect form and delicious filling once cut.

Step 8: Serve
To serve, drizzle melted dark chocolate over the top for a touch of elegance and sprinkle crushed Butterfinger pieces for extra crunch. You can top each slice with a mini Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup for a delightful finish. Enjoy your decadent creation, your Stuffed Cookie Pie will surely impress!

How to Store and Freeze Stuffed Cookie Pie

Fridge: Store leftover stuffed cookie pie in an airtight container for up to 5 days to maintain its fresh taste and texture.

Freezer: For longer storage, wrap the pie tightly in plastic wrap and then in aluminum foil, freezing it for up to 3 months.

Thawing: To enjoy frozen stuffed cookie pie, thaw it in the refrigerator overnight before serving. Warm up slices in the microwave for about 10-15 seconds for that just-baked experience.

Reheating: If refrigerated, gently reheat individual slices in the microwave for about 15 seconds for a lovely warm treat.

Stuffed Cookie Pie Variations

Feel free to adventure away from the traditional recipe and customize your stuffed cookie pie to suit your taste buds!

Nut-Free: Swap creamy peanut butter for sunflower seed butter for a delightful nut-free option that still retains that creamy texture.
Light & Fluffy: Replace marshmallow cream with homemade whipped cream for a lighter filling that’s oh-so-fluffy, making it a refreshing twist in every slice.
Decadent Chocolate: Use a variety of chocolate chips, such as dark chocolate or even white chocolate chips, to introduce a flavor complexity that can heighten your cookie experience.
Add Texture: Introduce crushed Oreo cookies or toffee bits into the filling for an exciting crunch that complements the chewy cookie crust beautifully.
Sweet & Spicy: Give it a kick with a dash of cayenne pepper in your cookie dough for a unique sweet and spicy flavor profile that tantalizes the taste buds.
Fruity Addition: Toss in fresh raspberries or strawberries between layers for a tart contrast that cuts through the sweetness, creating a delightful balance.
Caramel Drizzle: Finish your pie with a generous drizzle of homemade or store-bought caramel for an added layer of sweetness that works harmoniously with the chocolate-hazelnut spread.
Cocoa Twist: For true chocolate lovers, mix cocoa powder into your cookie dough for an extra chocolatey base that sets the tone for indulgence right from the start.

As you refine your masterpiece, consider serving it alongside a scoop of ice cream or a drizzle of hot fudge for even more mouthwatering goodness! If you’re in the mood for another delicious dessert, why not check out my recipe for a Double Chocolate Cookie? It’s rich and decadent too!

Expert Tips for Stuffed Cookie Pie

Avoid Melting: Allow the peanut butter to cool slightly before pouring it into the crust. This helps prevent excessive melting of the chocolate cups.
Chill for Perfection: Refrigerate the pie overnight for easier slicing and to let the flavors deepen. Patience is key!
Parchment Paper Advantage: Use parchment paper to line your pan; it makes removing the pie a breeze without compromising its integrity.
Monitor Baking Time: Keep an eye on the pie while baking. If the top browns too quickly, cover it loosely with foil to prevent burning.
Experiment with Fillings: Don’t be afraid to customize your Stuffed Cookie Pie! Mix in different candies or toppings for a personal touch.

Make Ahead Options

These decadent chocolate peanut butter stuffed cookie pies are perfect for meal prep enthusiasts! You can prepare the cookie crust and fill it with the desired ingredients up to 24 hours in advance, allowing the flavors to meld beautifully. Simply bake the pie when you’re ready to serve. To maintain quality, cover it tightly with plastic wrap and refrigerate overnight; this ensures each slice holds its shape and retains its deliciousness. When ready to enjoy, simply drizzle with melted dark chocolate and sprinkle with butterfinger pieces before serving for that extra touch of indulgence. With this make-ahead approach, you’ll have a crowd-pleasing dessert with minimal last-minute effort!

What to Serve with Decadent Chocolate Peanut Butter Stuffed Cookie Pie

Transform your dessert experience by pairing this indulgent pie with delightful accompaniments that enhance every bite.

Vanilla Ice Cream: A classic pairing, its creamy texture complements the warm, gooey filling and balances the sweetness.
Chocolate Drizzle: Enhance the decadence! Drizzling melted dark chocolate over individual slices adds an elegant touch and extra richness.
Whipped Cream: Light and fluffy, a dollop of whipped cream adds a refreshing contrast to the heavy pie and enhances its indulgence.
Fresh Berries: Raspberries or strawberries provide a tart pop that beautifully cuts through the richness of the stuffed cookie pie.
Coffee: Serve a warm cup of coffee or an espresso alongside to balance the sweet flavors, creating a perfect afternoon treat.
Milk Shake: For the ultimate indulgence, whip up a chocolate or vanilla milkshake, marrying creamy flavors with the rich pie.
Nutty Caramel Sauce: A drizzle of homemade or store-bought caramel sauce adds a delightful crunch and additional flavor layers, elevating your dessert allure.

Each pairing offers a unique twist that beautifully complements the rich flavors of your stuffed cookie pie!

Stuffed Cookie Pie Recipe FAQs

What type of butter is best for making the cookie crust?
Using salted butter adds richness and moisture that enhances the overall flavor of your stuffed cookie pie. If you prefer a less salty taste, feel free to substitute it with unsalted butter for a more balanced sweetness.

How should I store the leftover stuffed cookie pie?
To keep your delicious pie fresh, store any leftovers in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 5 days. This ensures that every slice remains moist and flavorful, ready to satisfy your dessert cravings!

Can I freeze stuffed cookie pie for later?
Absolutely! For long-term storage, wrap the pie tightly in plastic wrap and then in aluminum foil. It can be frozen for up to 3 months. When you’re ready to enjoy it, simply thaw it in the refrigerator overnight before serving.

What if my cookie pie is too soft or falls apart when cutting?
If you find your pie is too soft, it’s likely that it hasn’t chilled long enough. Make sure to refrigerate it overnight, as this allows the filling to set properly, making it easier to slice. Additionally, if the peanut butter is too hot when poured in, it can melt the chocolate cups, so let it cool slightly before layering.

Are there any dietary considerations I should keep in mind?
While this stuffed cookie pie is a decadent treat, those with peanut allergies should avoid using the creamy peanut butter or any chocolate with nut ingredients. You can substitute peanut butter with a seed butter like sunbutter for a nut-free alternative.

How do I achieve the perfect texture for the cookie crust?
For a chewy and soft cookie crust, make sure to cream your butter and sugars until they are light and fluffy—about 2 minutes. Additionally, sifting your dry ingredients helps incorporate air, which keeps the texture just right. Don’t forget to chill the pie before slicing; this allows the filling and crust to harmonize beautifully!